I Quit the Keto Diet—And Why It Made Me Feel Human Again

Posted on

I Quit the Keto Diet—And Why It Made Me Feel Human Again

Magazine

Image Credits: Wikimedia; licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Difficulty

Prep time

Cooking time

Total time

Servings

Author

Sharing is caring!

The Reality Behind the Keto Hype

The Reality Behind the Keto Hype (image credits: unsplash)
The Reality Behind the Keto Hype (image credits: unsplash)

Picture this: you’re scrolling through social media, and every other post is someone showing off their dramatic keto transformation. The before-and-after photos are shocking, the energy claims sound amazing, and suddenly you’re thinking, “Maybe I should try this too.” That’s exactly how my keto journey started three years ago. The ketogenic diet has emerged as a highly effective approach for rapid weight loss, aiming to facilitate weight loss, enhance mental clarity, and boost energy levels. The promise felt irresistible. But what I discovered after living the keto lifestyle for months was that sometimes the most liberating thing you can do is walk away from what everyone else calls “success.”

When Your Body Becomes a Fat-Burning Machine

When Your Body Becomes a Fat-Burning Machine (image credits: pixabay)
When Your Body Becomes a Fat-Burning Machine (image credits: pixabay)

The first few weeks on keto felt like I’d unlocked some secret superpower. The ketogenic diet changes the way your body uses food and teaches your body to burn fat for fuel instead. My energy was steady throughout the day—no more afternoon crashes that had me reaching for another cup of coffee. One of the biggest benefits of ketosis may be weight loss, as the process can help you feel less hungry, which may lead to eating less food. The scale was dropping fast, and I was getting compliments left and right. I thought I’d found the holy grail of dieting. But here’s what nobody talks about: your body burning fat for fuel doesn’t always feel as glamorous as it sounds. Some days, I felt like I was running on empty, even when the numbers said I should be thriving.

The Social Prison of Perfect Macros

The Social Prison of Perfect Macros (image credits: unsplash)
The Social Prison of Perfect Macros (image credits: unsplash)

Living on keto meant becoming a walking macro calculator. The keto diet is high in fat, moderate in protein and low in carbohydrates, consisting of 70% to 80% fats, 10% to 20% proteins and 5% to 10% carbohydrates. Every restaurant visit turned into a mental math problem. Birthday parties became minefields where I’d either eat nothing or awkwardly explain why I couldn’t have cake. You’ll have to cut out all bread, cereal and other grains and make serious cuts to your fruit and vegetable intake. Friends started making jokes about my “special diet,” and honestly, it hurt. Food had become the enemy instead of something to enjoy with people I loved. I missed the simple pleasure of sharing a meal without stress.

The Hidden Mental Health Struggle

The Hidden Mental Health Struggle (image credits: pixabay)
The Hidden Mental Health Struggle (image credits: pixabay)

What surprised me most was how keto affected my mental state—and not in the way the success stories promised. After moving on from a keto-focused job, one former adherent noticed that keto was no longer working as it once had, constantly feeling down, gaining weight, and dealing with chronic stress and insomnia, feeling crappy overall. While some research suggests keto might help with depression, my experience was the opposite. The keto diet may cause problems like nutrient deficiencies, kidney problems, liver issues, constipation, and mood swings. I became obsessed with staying in ketosis, checking my levels constantly like they were a report card for my worth. The anxiety around accidentally eating too many carbs was exhausting. Sleep became elusive, and I found myself irritated over the smallest things.

When Your Doctor Says “Stop”

When Your Doctor Says “Stop” (image credits: unsplash)

The wake-up call came during a routine check-up. Blood work revealed very high “bad” (LDL) cholesterol and decreased thyroid hormones. My doctor looked at my results and asked pointed questions about my diet. When I explained my strict keto lifestyle, she didn’t congratulate me on my weight loss—she looked concerned. An endocrinologist recommended stopping synthetic hormones and unnecessary supplements, noting that without a chronic health condition that keto could support, it would be wise to stop following the diet. That moment was both terrifying and liberating. I realized I’d been so focused on following the “rules” that I’d stopped listening to my body’s actual needs.

The Scary Truth About Long-Term Keto

The Scary Truth About Long-Term Keto (image credits: flickr)
The Scary Truth About Long-Term Keto (image credits: flickr)

What really opened my eyes was learning about the experiences of long-term keto followers. Some are now speaking out about unpleasant and persistent symptoms that arise over time, such as hormonal imbalances, sleep disturbances, muscle cramps, and mental fatigue. The influencers and success stories don’t usually talk about what happens after year two or three. Experts are raising alarms about potential nutritional deficiencies from following these restrictive diets, with many former dieters admitting they weren’t getting adequate vitamins and minerals, sometimes limiting meals to foods like chicken breast with cheese and heavy cream. I started wondering: was I setting myself up for health problems down the road? The research on long-term effects just isn’t there yet, and I didn’t want to be the experiment.

Breaking Up with Keto

Breaking Up with Keto (image credits: pixabay)
Breaking Up with Keto (image credits: pixabay)

Making the decision to quit keto felt like breaking up with a toxic relationship. I was scared of gaining weight, worried about losing the energy benefits, and honestly embarrassed about “failing” at something I’d been so vocal about. The plan involved slowly integrating healthy complex carbs and fruit back into life. But I also felt this incredible sense of relief, like I could finally breathe again. The first apple I ate after months of restriction was honestly emotional—it tasted like freedom. I had to remind myself that choosing my mental health over a number on the scale wasn’t failure; it was wisdom.

Rediscovering Food Joy

Rediscovering Food Joy (image credits: unsplash)
Rediscovering Food Joy (image credits: unsplash)

The transition off keto wasn’t instant magic, but it was magical in its own way. Following a temporary vegan diet, the experience included falling back in love with bananas, apples, sweet potatoes, beans, lentils, quinoa, oats and so many foods that had been avoided, along with food-related joy. I started cooking again—really cooking, not just assembling fat and protein. I could go to brunch with friends without stress. Date nights became fun again instead of negotiations about restaurant choices. Getting off the keto diet can bring health benefits if done the right way, with one result being better sleep. My sleep improved almost immediately, and that afternoon brain fog I’d attributed to carb withdrawal? It disappeared.

The Physical Changes That Surprised Me

The Physical Changes That Surprised Me (image credits: unsplash)
The Physical Changes That Surprised Me (image credits: unsplash)

Here’s what nobody prepared me for: quitting keto actually made me feel more energetic, not less. Sure, I gained some water weight initially—that’s completely normal when you reintroduce carbs. But within a few weeks, my workouts felt stronger, my recovery was faster, and I had sustained energy throughout the day. Following a more well-rounded diet that focuses on lean protein, healthy fats in moderation, gut-healthy foods and tons of plants became the new approach. My digestive system thanked me too. The constant low-level nausea I’d attributed to “fat adaptation” disappeared. I felt like my body was finally working with me instead of against me.

The Mental Freedom That Changed Everything

The Mental Freedom That Changed Everything (image credits: pixabay)
The Mental Freedom That Changed Everything (image credits: pixabay)

The biggest change wasn’t physical—it was mental. Looking back on five years of keto, it became clear that it had triggered some disordered eating behaviors like extreme restriction, chronic stress around food and extended periods of fasting. I stopped checking my ketone levels obsessively. Food became fuel and pleasure again, not a source of anxiety. The mental energy I’d been spending on macro calculations was suddenly available for other things—like actually enjoying my life. I could eat intuitively again, trusting my body’s hunger and fullness cues instead of overriding them with rigid rules. That trust was something I didn’t realize I’d lost until I got it back.

Finding Balance in a World of Extremes

Finding Balance in a World of Extremes (image credits: unsplash)
Finding Balance in a World of Extremes (image credits: unsplash)

What I learned from my keto experience is that the diet industry thrives on extremes, but real life happens in the middle. A balanced, whole-food, plant-forward diet is recommended, with Mediterranean or DASH diets having more documented mental health benefits and fewer associated risks. I’m not anti-keto—I know it genuinely helps some people, especially those with certain medical conditions. But for me, it became a lesson in the importance of listening to my body over following trends. To those considering the diet, it’s important to talk to a doctor or registered dietitian first to weigh the pros and cons and understand if it’s the right path. Now I eat a variety of foods, move my body because it feels good, and sleep better than I have in years.

Why “Feeling Human Again” Matters

Why “Feeling Human Again” Matters (image credits: flickr)

The only regret was waiting until health was suffering before realizing that keto was hurting more than helping. When I say keto made me feel human again after quitting, I mean it gave me back my relationship with food, my social connections, and my mental peace. I stopped living in fear of carbohydrates and started living in appreciation of balance. My energy comes from nourishing my body, not from forcing it into an unnatural state. I can eat birthday cake without guilt, travel without packing special snacks, and trust my body’s wisdom. That’s what feeling human means to me—being flexible, intuitive, and kind to yourself. The number on the scale matters far less than how you feel in your own skin.

Did you expect that breaking free from a “successful” diet could actually be the key to better health?

Author

Tags:

You might also like these recipes

Leave a Comment