Baked Alaska: The Theatrical Dessert That Lost Its Stage
Uploaded by Willscrlt, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=28575136)
Baked Alaska used to show up on restaurant menus as a special shared dessert but not so much anymore – except for old-school restaurants like Delmonico’s in NYC, which is said to have invented the dish to celebrate the US acquisition of Alaska in 1867. It showed up on restaurant menus, reportedly to celebrate the United States acquisition of Alaska from Russia. Sadly, you won’t find it on many menus now, replaced by new flavors and dessert recipes that lack the history of a true classic that has mostly disappeared from American dessert tables like so many other classic desserts.
The dessert’s complexity may explain its vanishing act. If you’ve never had it and want to try your hand, it takes about 45 minutes and some candy-making know-how that involves boiling sugar and corn syrup to a very high temperature, and the challenge of making it may be why it has disappeared in the past few decades. Once a showstopper that combined ice cream, sponge cake, and flame-torched meringue, Baked Alaska required both skill and showmanship. Modern restaurants often prioritize desserts that can be prepared quickly and consistently, leaving little room for such elaborate presentations. The theatrical element that once made diners gasp with delight now seems outdated in our fast-paced dining culture.
Chiffon Pie: The Airy Dessert That Couldn’t Stay Afloat
The chiffon pie was invented by Monroe Boston Strause – also known as the Pie King – in 1926 as a more modern, airy, and elegant alternative to heavy cream pies, which apparently reminded him of cornstarch pudding. This revolutionary dessert technique created something magical: a filling light as air yet rich in flavor. This recipe was once so popular that Strause covered some 30,000 miles each year to pass on his pie-making technique to professionals in hotels and restaurants.
The downfall of chiffon pie seems tied to changing preferences in dessert textures. This could be due to the treat’s light flavor and texture, with many sugar seekers today opting for richer dessert alternatives like cheesecakes and lava cakes. Americans have increasingly gravitated toward dense, indulgent desserts that photograph well for social media. The subtle elegance of chiffon pie, with its delicate foam and gentle sweetness, couldn’t compete with chocolate explosion cakes and towering sundaes. In an era where bigger and bolder often wins, this refined dessert quietly lost its place at the table.
Banana Pudding: The Southern Belle That Lost Her Crown
A sweet Southern classic, banana pudding used to be so popular that the recipe came on every box of Nilla Wafers. In the 70s and 80s, banana pudding showed up on tables all across the United States, thanks to the recipe finding its way into so many homes. This wasn’t just dessert; it was edible nostalgia served in layers. Nilla wafers, creamy pudding, fresh bananas, and fluffy meringue or whipped cream created a harmony that represented the best of American comfort food.
The decline of banana pudding reflects broader shifts in how we approach food preparation and eating habits. Modern consumers often seek more exotic flavors and Instagram-worthy presentations. The humble appearance of banana pudding, typically served in a simple glass dish or casserole pan, couldn’t compete with elaborate plated desserts. Additionally, the rise of health consciousness made many people wary of desserts containing artificial pudding mix and processed wafers. While banana pudding still exists in pockets of the South, it has largely vanished from mainstream restaurant menus across America, relegated to potluck dinners and family gatherings.
Whoopie Pies: Maine’s Sweet Secret Gone Missing
You may remember this fluffy, subtly-chocolate dessert from when you were a kid. These became an American staple dessert back in the early 1900s, but especially a huge hit in Maine and Pennsylvania. The whoopie pie represented American ingenuity at its finest: two soft cake-like cookies sandwiching a sweet cream filling. Originating from the Amish, the soft white filling sits perfectly between two cake-like cookies, and it’s no secret that everyone makes a mess while eating one every time.
Their disappearance from mainstream menus seems particularly puzzling given their perfect handheld format and nostalgic appeal. However, the rise of more sophisticated cookie and cake presentations may have pushed these humble treats aside. Cupcakes, macarons, and elaborate layer cakes captured the spotlight with their photogenic qualities and upscale positioning. The whoopie pie’s rustic appearance and messy eating style didn’t align with fine dining trends or social media aesthetics. While they remain beloved in certain regions, particularly Pennsylvania and Maine, they’ve become increasingly rare finds on restaurant dessert menus nationwide.
Apple Brown Betty: The Homestyle Classic That Couldn’t Adapt
This classic American dessert, sometimes called Apple Brown Betty, is a fruit-centric dessert in the same gene pool as the cobbler and apple crisp, and it first surfaced in the late 1800s. Typically, apples, pears, or berries are baked, and the fruit is then layered with sweet buttered crumbs and kissed with a dollop of whipped cream. This humble dessert has appeared on American tables for generations, beloved for its simple preparation and comforting flavors.
The dessert’s simplicity, once its greatest strength, became its weakness in an increasingly sophisticated culinary landscape. Unlike apple pie, which maintained its iconic status, Apple Brown Betty lacked a distinctive visual identity. Its humble crumb topping couldn’t compete with the dramatic lattice crusts and decorative elements that made other desserts more Instagram-worthy. Modern diners gravitated toward desserts with cleaner presentations and more defined textures, leaving this rustic comfort food behind. The rise of individual plated desserts in restaurants also worked against communal-style desserts like Apple Brown Betty, which were traditionally served family-style from large baking dishes.
Charlotte Russe: The Victorian Elegance That Time Forgot
Charlotte Russe, with its regal name and presentation, was once the star of dessert tables. This dessert was a favorite during the Victorian era, showcasing sophistication and class. Its origins are attributed to French chef Marie-Antoine Carême, who named it in honor of his royal patrons. The elaborate preparation required to make Charlotte Russe ensured that only those with a penchant for culinary arts attempted it.
The New York street version tells a different story of American adaptation. A simplified version of charlotte russe was a popular dessert or on-the-go treat sold in candy stores and luncheonettes in New York City, during the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s. It consisted of a paper cup filled with yellow cake and whipped cream topped with half a maraschino cherry. The dainty dessert is on the brink of extinction. Today, this elegant dessert exists primarily in culinary history books, unable to compete with modern dessert trends that favor bold flavors over delicate refinement. The time-intensive preparation and specialized technique required made it impractical for busy restaurant kitchens focused on efficiency and consistency.
Lady Baltimore Cake: The Wedding Belle’s Forgotten Glory
This classic American beauty was created with white cake layers and a fruity and toasted nut filling (figs, raisins, pecans, walnuts) and was crowned with boiled marshmallow icing. It was a Southern belle cake and often had a leading role as a wedding cake in the early 20th century. The cake’s elaborate composition made it a centerpiece worthy of the most important celebrations.
The Lady Baltimore cake apparently had nothing to do with the city of Baltimore, or a lady, for that matter. From most accounts, the origin of the cake’s name remains an enigma. Its decline parallels the shift away from labor-intensive desserts that required multiple components and specialized techniques. Modern wedding cakes favor cleaner aesthetics and simpler flavor profiles, often focusing on sophisticated buttercream work rather than complex fillings. The boiled marshmallow icing, once a mark of elegance, became seen as old-fashioned compared to contemporary fondant and ganache finishes. The cake’s association with a bygone era of formal dining ultimately contributed to its quiet disappearance from both wedding menus and restaurant offerings.
Syllabub: The Frothy English Import That Lost Its Fizz
Syllabub, a frothy concoction of cream, wine, and citrus, was once a fashionable dessert in England. Known for its airy texture and tangy flavor, it graced the tables of many a noble banquet. The tradition of making Syllabub involved a theatrical process of whipping the ingredients until they achieved the perfect froth. Often garnished with nutmeg or lemon zest, it was a visual and gustatory delight.
Although it has mostly disappeared from contemporary menus, its legacy survives in the annals of English culinary history. A resurgence of interest could bring this classic back to life. The dessert’s decline reflects changing attitudes toward alcohol in desserts and the modern preference for more stable, predictable textures. Syllabub’s ephemeral nature – its tendency to separate and deflate – made it unsuitable for restaurants that needed desserts with longer shelf lives. The specialized technique required to achieve the perfect froth also proved challenging in busy kitchen environments. While craft cocktail culture has embraced similar texture play, syllabub remains largely confined to historical cookbooks and culinary museums.
Blancmange: The Medieval Marvel That Modernization Forgot
Blancmange, a dessert with a name as smooth as its texture, is a sweet almond-flavored jelly. Traditionally made with milk or cream, sugar, and ground almonds, it was a staple at elegant gatherings. While today’s recipes for the sweet treat still vary, the panna cotta-like or firm pudding-like treat generally contains cornflour, milk, sugar, and flavoring such as vanilla, rosewater, or lemon.
The disappearance of blancmange reflects America’s complex relationship with gelatin-based desserts. While panna cotta gained popularity as an Italian import, blancmange’s English heritage couldn’t compete in the modern culinary landscape. The dessert’s subtle flavors and simple presentation seemed boring compared to elaborate chocolate desserts and colorful fruit tarts. Additionally, the rise of dairy-free and plant-based eating made traditional cream-heavy desserts like blancmange less appealing to health-conscious diners. The name itself, foreign and difficult to pronounce for many Americans, may have contributed to its decline as restaurants gravitated toward more recognizable dessert offerings.
Cherries Jubilee: The Flambéed Finale That Couldn’t Keep the Flame Alive
Cherries Jubilee once dazzled diners with its fiery presentation. This flambéed dessert, combining cherries and brandy, was a mid-century marvel. It brought drama to the dining table, often served with flair at upscale establishments. The decline began as dining trends shifted towards simpler and healthier desserts.
The death of tableside service contributed significantly to Cherries Jubilee’s disappearance. Cherries Jubilee was a favorite of mine when I was a kid (back in the sixties and seventies), and the family got dressed up and went to a nice restaurant for dinner. Didn’t happen often, but I made sure to have Cherries Jubilee for dessert if they had it. Modern restaurants eliminated many tableside preparations due to insurance concerns, staffing costs, and the need for specially trained servers. The dessert’s reliance on dramatic presentation meant it lost its essential appeal when served pre-prepared from the kitchen. Additionally, changing attitudes toward alcohol consumption and fire safety in restaurants made flambéed desserts less practical. The rise of fast-casual dining and the emphasis on efficient service models left no room for such theatrical dessert experiences.
The story of America’s vanishing desserts reflects more than just changing tastes. It reveals how our entire relationship with food, dining, and tradition has transformed. These disappeared desserts represent a time when patience was valued over speed, when technique mattered more than convenience, and when the dining experience included elements of surprise and ceremony that we rarely see today.
What strikes me most about this culinary archaeology is how quietly it all happened. No one made a conscious decision to eliminate these desserts from our collective menu. Instead, they faded away as restaurants chased efficiency, diners demanded Instagram-worthy presentations, and our palates shifted toward bolder, more immediate flavors. The elaborate techniques, time-intensive preparations, and subtle sophistication that defined these desserts simply couldn’t compete in our modern food landscape.
Perhaps there’s a lesson here about the value of preserving culinary traditions before they disappear entirely. These desserts weren’t just sweet endings to meals – they were edible connections to our history, markers of celebration, and expressions of regional identity. What do you think? Should we be making more effort to preserve these vanishing sweets, or is this just the natural evolution of American cuisine?
