A Beloved Food Critic Passes Away
Marilyn Hagerty, the longtime columnist and food critic for the Grand Forks Herald who became an internet sensation for her earnest Olive Garden review, has died at the age of 99. Her family confirmed her passing on September 16 after complications from a recent stroke.
Family Confirms Her Passing
Her son, James “Bob” Hagerty, shared the news with TODAY.com, noting that funeral services will be held on October 6. She is survived by her son James, daughter Gail Hagerty, and eight grandchildren. Another daughter, Carol Werner, passed away in 2011.
A Viral Moment In 2012
Hagerty first went viral in 2012 when her straightforward and heartfelt review of a new Olive Garden in Grand Forks captured national attention. She praised the chain’s chicken Alfredo as “warm and comforting on a cold day” and described the restaurant as “the largest and most beautiful” in the city.
A Lifelong Career In Journalism
Marilyn Hagerty spent nearly seven decades writing for the Grand Forks Herald. She launched her “Eatbeat” column when her hometown offered only a handful of fine dining spots, helping readers navigate new eateries and national chains alike.
Champion Of Everyday Dining
Unlike traditional critics, Hagerty focused on making restaurants approachable to everyday readers. She reviewed chains such as Taco Bell, Ruby Tuesday, and McDonald’s, offering clear information about menu options, pricing, and atmosphere rather than harsh judgment.
Admired By Culinary Greats
Her kindness and honest voice resonated far beyond Grand Forks. Celebrity chef Anthony Bourdain became an admirer, even editing her 2013 book Grand Forks: A History of American Dining in 128 Reviews. In his foreword, Bourdain praised her generosity and gentle humor.
Revisiting Olive Garden Years Later
Eight years after her viral review, Hagerty returned to Olive Garden to order her beloved chicken Alfredo again. She later appeared on TODAY in 2020, reflecting on her unexpected fame and how small-town dining could still connect with people nationwide.
